Picture the scene. You pour your morning tea, boot up your PC, and discover your government has just greenlit a psychological horror fest for your four-year-old nephew, while slapping an 18+ certificate on a cartoon horse race. It sounds like a rejected Monty Python sketch, but this is exactly the kaleidoscope of madness that just unfolded across Indonesia.
People are treating this like a funny tech hiccup, but they’re missing the real pattern. This is what happens when a process designed for human judgment gets entirely handed over to a box-ticking exercise.
The Absurd Board State
On one side, we have Uma Musume Pretty Derby—a perfectly harmless game about anime girls running around a track. According to the new Indonesian ratings drop, this is strictly adults-only territory. Heaven forbid a teenager witnesses a cartoon filly jumping a hurdle.
- Metaphor: ReFantazio and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 — world-class RPGs — were stamped
inadequate,
practically banning them from sale in the region entirely. - The Song of Saya — a visual novel dripping with cosmic gore and explicit psychological torment — received a shiny green sticker approving it for ages three and up.
- Nukitashi, a game that makes no bones about being an outright eroge, also waltzed through with the same toddler-friendly rating.
A toddler could legally buy them. The gaming community watched the algorithm walk straight off a cliff and filled the forums with the appropriate amount of ridicule.
How the System Failed
So how does a system manage to get it entirely backwards? A spectacular failure of oversight. Valve decided to automate their Indonesian IGRS tags based on surveys filled out by the developers themselves, rather than forcing the games through the government’s actual human review.
Let the folks selling the product grade their own homework, and suddenly the horror novels become picture books.
It’s the corporate equivalent of leaving the front door wide open and acting surprised when the dog escapes.
The Official Response
Faced with an absolute battering on the global stage, the IGRS board had to step out of the shadows. They issued a hasty emergency statement clarifying that these absurdities weren’t their final rulings, insisting they are now working at full tilt with Steam to untangle the web.
For now, Valve has quietly hit the undo button, falling back to standard international ratings while they figure out how to fix the unfixable.
The Bigger Question
When corporations hand the keys of regional compliance to an automated survey to save time, are we witnessing a temporary technological hiccup, or the inevitable cost of valuing scale over accuracy?
And if developer self-reporting produces outcomes this completely detached from reality, shouldn’t mandatory manual review simply be the baseline cost of doing business?




Leave a Comment